June 6, 2013

Let’s Get Real about Same-sex Marriage

Some time ago, I began writing an essay titled “Christianity and Gay Marriage” in which I intended to take on opposition to same-sex marriage by Christians. I began by enumerating the benefits of marriage and intended to argue that marriage could benefit both same-sex couples and society as a whole. As my list lengthened, I began to worry that my essay would do so as well, and I put the project aside to be taken up later.

I was thinking about that essay today, perhaps inspired by the fact that the religious forces in the U.K. seem to have given up on derailing the same-sex marriage bill making its way through Parliament in favor of trying to amend the bill to make it more to their liking. It occurred to me that the question is not really why people should be allowed to marry someone of the same sex but why they should be prevented from doing so.

The basic answer as to why same-sex marriage should be allowed is that there are people who want to marry someone of the same sex. This is not as silly as it might sound. In the past, there was virtually no demand for this right, and the largely unexamined tradition of allowing marriage only between men and women went unchallenged. Once the demand for the right to marry someone of the same sex is made in what claims to be a free society, the question that has to be asked is: why not?

Once consciousnesses has been raised, right-thinking people find it difficult to support the status quo absent strong reasons for doing so. Many examples of this phenomenon could be cited from the civil rights movement or the women’s movement. Let me suggest an example that is not too fraught with emotion.

I once found it natural and acceptable to use masculine pronouns where the sex of the referent is indefinite. (“Everyone picked up his books and left the classroom.”) When feminists objected to this convention as sexist, I had to change my practice in speech and writing. The old convention seemed perfectly serviceable, and I did not mean to offend anyone by employing it. When I discovered that some people did take offense (even if they had been taught to take offense), however, I had to change my practice because the objection was logical and the hurt inflicted by the longstanding convention was real. (Alas, we still haven’t found a good grammatical solution to the problem of lacking a sufficiently diverse set of personal pronouns.)

For most of my life, I never though about allowing people of the same sex to marry, but I cannot not think about it now. And when forced to think about it, there seems little reason two people of the same sex cannot live together, sharing their lives and possessions, providing mutual support, and even raising children. Nonetheless, certain religious people, invariably Christians, it seems, are unmoved by the obvious logic. They have reasons to object to allowing same-sex marriage. I want to consider the arguments most often raised by such folks against extending society’s concept of marriage.

Perhaps the most common argument one hears is that gay marriage will somehow damage conventional marriage. It is difficult to take this argument seriously, as a mechanism for such damage is never identified. How is one’s marriage diminished by allowing another couple of whatever sort to marry? In fact, there is only one substantive and objective disadvantage that would be visited on heterosexual married couples by allowing people of the same sex to marry. That disadvantage is financial. Since there are financial benefits to being married—being able to file joint tax returns, for example—the societal cost of those benefits would be borne by everyone. I suspect that most people who say that same-sex marriage will damage conventional marriage are not thinking of this and, if they are, they are reluctant to say so, as to do so would seem (and would be) selfish and uncharitable. I believe this argument is a smokescreen for some deeper misgivings, most likely for simple homophobia.

Many claim that a mother and a father are necessary to raise children and that, for the sake of children, we should not encourage the formation of same-sex families. I hardly know where to start discussing this argument, as there is so much wrong with it. To begin with, not everyone who marries will rear or even want to rear children. Even if one grants that a mother and father are necessary to rear children, society does not demand that married people do so. Children are being reared successfully, if not ideally, by single parents and even by same-sex couples. Allowing same-sex marriage might at least increase the number of children in two-parent households, which is almost assuredly more desirable than having them grow up in single-parent households. In fact, the insistence on the need for a mother and a father relies on stereotyped gender roles and the idea that it is helpful for children to be exposed to different personality types. However, a couple, whether heterosexual or homosexual, may be composed of people of very similar or very different personalities. Many homosexual couples surely exhibit more psychological and behavioral diversity than do many heterosexual couples. A similar statement could be made about heterosexual couples. Significantly, we do not test potential mates for diversity before allowing them to marry. The argument about children may be more sincere than the damage-to-conventional-marriage argument, but it is no more compelling.

Then there is the complementarianism argument, the notion that men and women are, in some abstract sense, equal, but have different God-given roles. Those roles do not include marrying someone of the same sex, a view for which Genesis 1–2 is usually cited. Taken to its logical conclusion, this argument suggests that a marriage of people of the same sex is intrinsically disordered and, probably, doomed. To the degree that this argument is the result of sincere religious belief, it is difficult to counter. One suspects, however, that, at its heart, this argument is one of certain body parts fitting into certain other body parts. This represents a narrow view of what marriage is all about. (No doubt there would be more happy marriages if marriage was only about having sex and not about supporting one another, reaching compromises, taking out the garbage, and facing life’s difficulties together.) As an empirical matter, as I suggested above, differences between people are not simply determined by sex. Moreover, in modern industrial (or post-industrial) society, most roles are or could be filled by either males or females. (We may never see female Navy SEALs, but this role is an exception.) The notion that each sex has its own God-defined role is no less offensive than the notion that I heard expressed so often in the South when I was growing up, namely that—excuse the language—niggers should know their place. There are many same-sex couples who have lived for decades in happy circumstances, thereby providing ample counterexamples to this argument. To the degree that it is not simply an article of faith, it is bogus.

Another argument that is frequently articulated is that marriage has always been what the church says it is now, and the church is disinclined to change. This, too, is nonsense, but many people who should know better espouse it, whether or not they actually believe it. No less a churchman than the current Archbishop of Canterbury seems to be saying “this is what the Church of England has always said, and we’re sticking with it.” What can one say to that?

For some people, perhaps for many people who offer one of the foregoing arguments, the real issue is either that they believe homosexuality is a sin that should not be tolerated, or they simply have an aversion to the idea of homosexuality, i.e., they are pure homophobes. Such people are not easily dissuaded from their view.

An argument that can be deployed to counter religious opposition to same-sex marriage is that, in a democratic, pluralistic society, laws should not be determined by religious ideas of right and wrong unless those views are very—and I emphasize very—widely accepted. Thus, homicide is outlawed, but working on the Sabbath isn’t. Of course, this argument doesn’t work on those who insist that the United States is and has always been meant to be a “Christian country.” Such people think they want to live in a theocracy, but they might have second thoughts were they actually to find themselves living in one.

All the arguments against allowing same-sex marriage are weak, at best. Perhaps the most compelling answer to them, however, should be informed by the fact that both the Church of England and the Roman Catholic Church in the U.K. have concluded that legislation allowing same-sex marriage is inevitable because the populace, including their politicians, seems to be in favor of it. In fact, the Pew Research Center for the People & the Press has just today released a report showing that a majority of both proponents and opponents of legal same-sex unions believe that legalization is inevitable. Why don’t we accept the inevitable and move on to discussion of more urgent issues, such as unemployment, our failed banking regulation, or our corrupt system of financing elections?

16 comments:

  1. "The basic answer as to why same-sex marriage should be allowed is that there are people who want to marry someone of the same sex."

    YES!!! This argument is SO overdue. Too often, endless trips down the rabbit-hole are run, that are so much neverending philosophical/rhetorical/theological/argumentive, well, "self-abuse". Enough!

    You have a loving, same-sex couple, and they want to marry. Boom. Done. Get out of their way!

    ReplyDelete
  2. King of Escorts in Dubai is the best platform in Dubai. Our agency provide you more hot and sexy Escorts models in Dubai on Cheap prices. They are all well trained and professional Escorts from many Years in Dubai.
    Ecorts in Dubai
    Pakistani Ecorts in Dubai
    Indian Ecorts in Dubai
    Indian Pakistani Escorts in Dubai
    Models Escorts in Dubai

    ReplyDelete
  3. Our agency Kings of Dubai provide you the best and hot models in Dubai on cheap price. if you need contact with us Visit our site.
    Ecorts in Dubai
    Pakistani Ecorts in Dubai
    Indian Ecorts in Dubai
    Indian Pakistani Escorts in Dubai
    Models Escorts in Dubai

    ReplyDelete
  4. Great post! I just stumbled your blog and needed to say that I have truly delighted reading your blog entries. Any way I'll be subscribing to your feed and I trust you post again soon.
    Ecorts in Dubai
    Pakistani Ecorts in Dubai
    Indian Ecorts in Dubai
    Indian Pakistani Escorts in Dubai
    Models Escorts in Dubai

    ReplyDelete
  5. Owsam Very nice post i read this post more then 4 time and every tim e i learn somthing new its very helpful for me i am very thankful to you to share this post with us

    Indian escorts in Dubai
    Pakistani escorts in Dubai
    Indian Pakistani escorts in Dubai
    Student escorts in Dubai

    ReplyDelete
  6. I really appreciate your work. Your blogs contains very interesting information according to my requirement and It will be really pleasing if you uploads more. Pakistani Escorts In Dubai

    ReplyDelete
  7. Modular Kitchens , wardrobes, Internal cabinet, False ceiling, office door, safety doors manufacturer, exporter, dealer in Noida, Delhi NCR, Gurgaon, Faridabad - We are leading wardrobe and modular kitchen design and manufacturer in Noida Delhi NCR, modular kitchen dealer in Noida. For low price kitchen dealer in Noida, Delhi NCR, Gurgaon, Faridabad you should contact with us.

    Click Hear Wardrobes in Gurgaon
    Click Hear Wardrobes in Noida
    Click Hear Wardrobes in Delhi-NCR
    Click Hear SABY international
    Click Hear Modular kitchens saby international
    Click Hear Modular Kitchens in India
    Click Hear Modular Kitchens in Gurgaon
    Click Hear Modular Kitchens in Noida
    Click Hear Modular Kitchens in Faridabad
    Click Hear Modular kitchens in Delhi-NCR

    ReplyDelete
  8. With a constant endeavor on improvising our Quality service, products quality and new ideas for over two decades, we have travelled a very long journey of success in a very short time. This proves the company’s standard and success story from a Brick to a Building year after year At Nahata Comfort, we not only just have the latest techniques, machineries and ample infrastructure in our Manufacturing unit to meet up with the higher standard of product quality, but also a team of highly qualified and enthusiastic professionals, constantly striving for high quality product profile and high quality service.

    Click Here:- Manufacturer, exporter & supplier of Submersible Pump for air cooler in faridabad
    Click Here:- Manufacturer, exporter & supplier of Cooler Pump in faridabad
    Click Here:- Manufacturer, exporter & supplier of Cooler motor for air cooler in faridabad
    Click Here:- Manufacturer, exporter & supplier of Exhaust fan in faridabad
    Click Here:- Manufacturer, exporter & supplier of Monoblock Pump in faridabad
    Click Here:- Manufacturer, exporter & supplier of Gas Geyser in faridabad
    Click Here:- Manufacturer, exporter & supplier of electric motor in faridabad
    Click Here:- Manufacturer, exporter & supplier Cooler fan Blade Mounting arms and accessories in faridabad
    Click Here:- Manufacturer, exporter & supplier of Ceiling Fan Regulator in faridabad
    Click Here:- Manufacturer, exporter & supplier of Ventilating fan, fresh air fan in faridabad

    VISIT WEB LINK : Wedding planner in Jaipur
    VISIT WEB LINK : Wedding planner in Jaisalmer
    VISIT WEB LINK : Wedding planner in Jodhpur
    VISIT WEB LINK : Wedding planner in Udaipur
    VISIT WEB LINK : Wedding planner in Goa
    VISIT WEB LINK : Wedding planner in Rajasthan
    VISIT WEB LINK : Destination wedding planner in Jaipur
    VISIT WEB LINK : Royal wedding planner in Jaipur
    VISIT WEB LINK : Beach Weeding planner in Goa
    VISIT WEB LINK : Cost of weeding in in Rajasthan
    VISIT WEB LINK : Cost of weeding in Udaipur
    VISIT WEB LINK : Cost of weeding in Jaipur
    VISIT WEB LINK : Cost of weeding in Jodhpur

    ReplyDelete
  9. We are Faridabad based company which is located in middle of Palwal and Delhi on Mathura Agra Highway, we manufacture Kids Playground Equipment and Sports equipment as our main products. Major cities we cover are Delhi NCR, Gurgaon, Noida, Ghaziabad, Faridabad, Agra, Mathura, Sohna, Palwal, Hathin, Rohtak, Panipat, Sonipat, Jind, Hisar, Kanpur, Jaipur, Sikar, hodal, Kosi Kalan, Rewari, Narnaul, Hapur.

    Visit It:- Frp Playground Equipment in Gurgaon
    Visit It:- Playground Equipments in Gurgaon
    Visit It:- School Playground Equipment in Gurgaon
    Visit It:- Outdoor Playground Equipment in Gurgaon
    Visit It:- Playground Swing in Gurgaon
    Visit It:- Playground Equipment Manufacturer in Gurgaon
    Visit It:- Children Playground Equipment in Gurgaon
    Visit It:- Kids Children Playground Equipment Manufacturer in Gurgaon
    Visit It:- Playground Multiplay Swing System Cities in Gurgaon
    Visit It:- School Outdoor Playground Equipment Cities in Gurgaon

    Visit It:- Frp Playground Equipment in Noida
    Visit It:- Playground Equipments in Noida
    Visit It:- School Playground Equipment in Noida
    Visit It:- Outdoor Playground Equipment in Noida
    Visit It:- Playground Swing in Noida
    Visit It:- Playground Equipment Manufacturer in Noida
    Visit It:- Children Playground Equipment in Noida
    Visit It:- Kids Children Playground Equipment Manufacturer in Noida
    Visit It:- Playground Multiplay Swing System Cities in Noida
    Visit It:- School Outdoor Playground Equipment Cities in Noidan

    ReplyDelete
  10. GIHWC is a concept of mind, body and soul. The Center is the perfect place for people who want to look their best!!.We offer and practice a wide variety of the most advanced procedure & Aesthetic equipment available today. We make nutritional balance through proper diet and give a body customized shaping through well known German technologies.

    Visi It:- Best Nutrition consultation in faridabad
    Visi It:- Best Weightloss centre in faridabad
    Visi It:- Diet Clinic - Weight Loss Clinic
    Visi It:- Best Nutritionist in faridabad
    Visi It:- Green India Health Care
    Visi It:- Best Pregnancy Diet Planner in faridabad
    Visi It:- Best Pregnancy Diet Plans in Delhi NCR
    Visi It:- Best diet programs in faridabad
    Visi It:- Best diet programs for active and healthy kids in faridabad
    Visi It:- Best dietitian for active and healthy kids in faridabad
    Visi It:- Best dietitian for kids in faridabad
    Visi It:- Diet Clinic for active and healthy kids in Delhi NCR
    Visi It:- Diet centres for active and healthy kids in faridabad
    Visi It:- Best weight loss programs in faridabad
    Visi It:- Best Weight loss clinic in faridabad
    Visi It:- Weight loss Clinic in Delhi NCR
    Visi It:- Best Weight reduce centres in faridabad
    Visi It:- How to reduce weight in faridabad
    Visi It:- How to lose weight fast in faridabad
    Visi It:- Diet programs in faridabad
    Visi It:- Diet plans for women in faridabad
    Visi It:- How to lose weight naturally in faridabad
    Contact us:
    Ph No. : +91-9958486667
    Website : http://greenindiahealthcare.in/

    ReplyDelete

  11. Visit It:- Wedding planner in Jaipur
    Visit It:- Wedding planner in Jaisalmer
    Visit It:- Modular kitchen manufacturer in Noida
    Visit It:- Modular kitchen manufacturer in delhi ncr
    Visit It:- Modular kitchen manufacturer in Faridabad
    Visit It:- Modular kitchen manufacturer in Gurgaon
    Visit It:- Modular kitchen dealer in Noida
    Visit It:- Modular kitchen dealer in delhi ncr
    Visit It:- Modular kitchen dealer in Faridabad
    Visit It:- Modular kitchen dealer in Gurgaon
    Visit It:- Best Modular kitchen manufacturer in Noida
    Visit It:- Best Modular kitchen manufacturer in Faridabad
    Visit It:- Best Modular kitchen manufacturer in Gurgaon
    Visit It:- Best Modular kitchen manufacturer in Delhi-NCR
    Visit It:- Modular kitchen supplier in Noida
    Visit It:- Modular kitchen supplier in Faridabad
    Visit It:- Modular kitchen supplier in Gurgaon
    Visit It:- Modular kitchen supplier in Delhi-NCR
    Visit It:- Modular kitchen exporter in Noida
    Visit It:- Modular kitchen exporter in Faridabad
    Visit It:- Modular kitchen exporter in Gurgaon
    Visit It:- Modular kitchen exporter in Delhi-NCR
    Visit It:- wardrobes manufacturer in Noida
    Visit It:- wardrobes manufacturer in Faridabad
    Visit It:- wardrobes manufacturer in Gurgaon
    Visit It:- wardrobes manufacturer in Delhi-NCR
    Visit It:- wardrobes dealer in Noida
    Visit It:- wardrobes dealer in Faridabad
    Visit It:- wardrobes dealer in Gurgaon
    Visit It:- wardrobes dealer in Delhi-NCR
    Visit It:- Best wardrobes manufacturer in Noida
    Visit It:- Best wardrobes manufacturer in Faridabad
    Visit It:- Best wardrobes manufacturer in Gurgaon
    Visit It:- Best wardrobes manufacturer in Delhi-NCR
    Visit It:- wardrobes supplier in Noida

    ReplyDelete
  12. The company holds a very strong team of mechanical engineers having specialization in fields such as sales, service, installation of earthing equipments etc. Laxmi Power Solutions is able to reach out most of the earthing equipments in the town. We are specialized company in producing total solution for Lightning Protection and Chemical Earthing.

    Chemical Earthing in Faridabad
    Chemical Earthing Electrode in Delhi NCR

    GI Earthing Electrode in Gurgaon
    GI Chemical Earthing Electrode in Noida
    Copper Chemical Earthing Electrodes in Faridabad

    Plate Earthing in Delhi NCR
    GI Plate Earthing in Gurgaon
    Copper Plate Earthing in Noida
    Conventional Earthing in Faridabad
    Pit Covers in Delhi NCR
    Earthing Lighting Arrester in Gurgaon
    Copper Bonded Earthing Rods in Noida
    Copper Bonded Grounding Rods in Faridabad

    Contact us:-
    phone: 9999741959
    website: http://www.laxmipowersolutions.com/
    Email: laxmipowersolution80@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete

Anonymous comments are not allowed. All comments are moderated by the author. Gratuitous profanity, libelous statements, and commercial messages will be not be posted.